Everyone who was there
Will remember
Where they were An updated version of an essay I originally wrote in 2007, posted on 5/1/11: It’s just a square on the calendar like any other: I’m going fight my way out of sleep, go to work, exercise, eat dinner and settle in to a relaxing evening on the couch, probably staying up past my bedtime. I never think it will be different, but when I finally do get out of bed the inevitable radio news story on the anniversary makes me pause with one hand on the cereal, one hand rubbing my eyes.
“I suppose it is September 11,” I think, girding myself behind a wall of intellectual distance as I pour the cereal and sit to eat. Then the radio goes silent. Like the discordant tone of an over-wound piano wire, I feel a twinge reverberating inside me, tightening my gut.
It’s 8:46 a.m., the exact moment American Airlines flight 11 hit the north tower in 2001. My tightened stomach brings me back to high school; I’m a teenager, herded with my peers into the gothic chapel our school used for assemblies.
The enormous room’s Tiffany stained glass windows shine in the bright September air of a school year less than a week old. Shuffling into a pew, I hear whispers that a plane had hit the World Trade Center, but I don’t believe them, there must be some other reason for this unplanned gathering.
A phalanx of copper organ pipes close rank behind the headmaster when he takes the podium. Wasting no time, he spits the news: an airliner has crashed into the World Trade Center. The government believes it was a terrorist act. With his slender, brass soldiers still guarding him from attack, he tells us to go to our classes, carry on as if nothing unusual has happened. Of course, no one goes to class.
My thoughts immediately fly to my Mom, her office is across the street from the Trade Center. I walk through the complex’s enormous courtyard to visit her from the 4 train on Fulton Street, the towers soaring skyward above.
Once dismissed, I bound through halls and leap down stairs, all but flying to the pay phone. It’s 2001 and my friends all have cell phones, but I’ve resisted the trend, and now regret my stubbornness for the first time. I dial Mom’s office and get no answer. A lump starts to form in my throat. I try her cell. No answer. My stomach starts performing backflips – ungainly, wobbly ones that you might see a clown perform at the circus. Was my face green like a cartoon characters? Probably, given the horror show in my head:
What if her building was next? Would she know to leave? Would she be able to leave? How could she get home, the subway was in the Trade Center!
I call home and get no answer. With trembling fingers, I dial my Dad’s office with the same result. Taking a deep breath and blinking back tears, I call Dad’s cell. Mercifully, he answered.
With a tremble in my voice, I ask if Mom is OK.
“Mom’s fine, she went with some co-workers uptown to someone’s apartment,” he tells me. “She’s going to come home as soon as she can.” With a shudder of relief, I hang up the phone and sling myself down to the rubber flooring, slumping against a radiator. I close my eyes, realizing that my temples are pounding. I should be relieved, but something is still wrong. I think of my brother. He’s 13, in eighth grade.
Would he know to call Dad’s cell? Would he be as scared as I had been? Maybe he wouldn’t be worried at all.
I thought of a time he and I had gotten separated from our parents while skiing. I was eleven or so, and I was a worried little kid. No, I was a panicked little kid. If we couldn’t find our parents, how would we get back to the hotel? How would we get back to Brooklyn? How would we eat? I wanted to find a payphone to call our grandparents to come from Florida to rescue us, because that made sense to me. Eric was cool through it all, even as I was preparing for the sky to fall. He told me not to worry, and not to call grandma who would surely ask embarrassing questions about girls. Eric was right, we found our parents in short order and got on with vacation.
No, this isn’t like that. Mom could have been in real danger and Eric would recognize that. Without even considering going to class, I’m off to find him, searching all the likely places an eighth grader might be.
As I encountered my classmates in the halls, everyone wore the same shell-shocked expression. We were scared and confused. Nobody was going to class. We didn’t know what was going on or what would happen next, but we could see the tower burning through the windows.
Then another plane hit the south tower. News flooded the somber corridors, contributing, of course, to the terror. Then the Pentagon was hit, the White House, the National Mall, the Washington Monument, the Empire State Building, the Sears Tower, the Space Needle and Mt. Rushmore. Rumor supplanted truth and the knot in my stomach grew to watermelon size. My bowels were going to release and my heart was going to stop. What if Brooklyn was next? Prospect Park seemed like a likely target. Hell, even our school could be hit; we’re only a block from Borough Hall.
And still, I couldn’t find Eric.
Then the south tower collapsed. It fell straight down, but the radio in the drama teacher’s office said it could have tipped in any direction, had a gust of wind shown up at the crucial moment. Thousands died, just like that. It could have tipped toward Mom’s building just like that.
I just want to go home, dive into bed and pull the covers over my head until it’s safe again, but first, I need to tell my brother that Mom is OK. I have to tell him, who else will?
Peering into empty classrooms while trying to maintain a dignified expression, I start thinking about the last time the World Trade Center was bombed, in 1996. I was 8 then. It was snowing. My Mom didn’t work on Fridays back then, so I wasn’t scared. I didn’t understand what had happened, or why we were sitting in the house watching the news on TV when we could have been outside playing in the snow. I knew her office was across the street form the two giant towers, but it didn’t seem like a big deal.
A couple weeks later, we saw Mom’s friend on the subway. She was breathing oxygen through a tube in her nose. I asked my Mom, in the way only an 8-year old can, why the lady had a tube in her nose. Mom told me that the woman had been in the World Trade Center when it was bombed. She’d been trapped in the dark, walking down an endless staircase, not sure if she’d make it to the bottom. Mom said the stairwell filled with choking smoke, and some people ran down, pushing aside anyone in their way. The oxygen was helping Mom’s friend recover.
Oh.
I was 8, but I sure understood the bombing a little better.
What if the bombing hadn’t been on a Friday, Mom? What if you had been at work? What if it was on a Tuesday?
Finally, I find my brother with a school administrator who, despite the general chaos in the school, had the presence of mind to collect children whose parents worked in the towers. They’re trying to contact Mom by phone, but of course, as I’d already discovered, the phones are dead. They hadn’t thought to try Dad. My brother, far from joking around, is near tears.
“Mom’s OK,” I tell him, blinking back my own tears.
Looking back, I think I hugged him, I sure hope I did.
The original version:I always forget how Sept. 11 pulls on my heartstrings. In the days leading up to the anniversary, I always think it’ll be the same as any other day. I’ll go to work, get some exercise; maybe I’ll eat pasta for dinner, or maybe a burrito. Intellectually, I know that it’s the anniversary, but it doesn’t seem any different from any other day.And then I wake up that morning and turn on the radio. Inevitably, there’s a broadcast of the memorial service from Ground Zero.“Oh, it’s September 11,” I think. Then I sit down to eat a banana and some cereal, and everything is fine until the radio goes silent. It’s always at 8:46 a.m., the exact moment when American Airlines flight 11 hit the north tower. And suddenly, I’m back in high school. I’m 16, and I’m a junior, being herded like a lamb with all my peers into the Gothic chapel our school used as an assembly hall. The Tiffany stained glass windows shown in the bright September air. The school year was less than a week old. As we shuffled into our pews there were whispers that a plane had hit the World Trade Center, but I didn’t believe it, there must be some other reason for this unplanned gathering.Mr. Pearson, our usually affable and energetic headmaster, took the podium with a look of such consternation on his face that I knew something big was up. He told us, in very plain words, that an airliner had been crashed into the building, and that the government believed it was a terrorist act. He told us to go to our classes and to carry on with our day as if nothing unusual had happened. But something unusual had happened.My thoughts immediately flew to my Mom. She worked across the street from the Trade Center. I walked through the complex’s enormous courtyard to get to her office from the 4 train stop on Fulton Street.As soon as Mr. Pearson dismissed us I ran to the pay phone. All my peers had cell phones, but I thought it was cool to resist the trend. I dialed Mom’s office. No answer. A lump formed in my throat. I called her cell. No answer. My stomach twisted into a knot.What if her building was next? Would she know to leave? Would she be able to leave? How could she get home, the subway was in the Trade Center! I called home, no answer there either. With trembling fingers, I dialed my Dad’s home office, and there was no answer. Taking a deep breath, and blinking back tears, I called Dad’s cell. Mercifully, he answered.With a tremble in my voice, I asked if Mom was OK.“Mom’s fine, she went with some co-workers to someone’s apartment in Stuyvesant Village,” Dad said. “She’s going to come home as soon as she can.” With a shudder of relief, I hung up the phone and slumped against the wall. I closed my eyes, but something was still wrong. I thought of my brother. He was 13, in eighth grade.Would he know to all Dad’s cell? Would he be as scared as I had been? Maybe he wouldn’t be worried at all.I thought of a time he and I had gotten separated from our parents on a ski slope. I was eleven or so, and I was a worried little kid. No, I was a panicked little kid. If we couldn’t find our parents, how would we get back to the hotel? How would we get back to Brooklyn? How would we eat? In that moment, I was ready to find a payphone to call our grandparents to come rescue us, even though they were in Florida and we were in Colorado. Eric remained cool through it all. He told me not to worry. Sure enough, we found our parents in short order and got on with our vacation.No, this wasn’t like that, I decided, Mom could have been in real danger. Surely Eric would recognize that. Without even considering going to class, I took off to find him, searching all the likely places an eighth grader might be.As I encountered my classmates in the halls, we all wore the same pallid expression. We were scared. We didn’t know what was going on, we didn’t know what was going to happen, and you could see the tower burning through the windows. Then the second plane hit. News traveled like a wave through the school. Then, the Pentagon was hit, the White House, the National Mall, the Washington Monument, the Empire State Building, the Sears Tower, Seattle’s Space Needle. Rumor supplanted truth and the knot in my stomach grew to watermelon size. I felt simultaneously like my bowels were going to release and my heart was going to stop. What if Brooklyn was next. Prospect Park seemed like a likely target. Hell, even our school seemed like a likely target, we were only a block from Borough Hall!And still, I couldn’t find Eric.Then the south tower collapsed. It fell straight down, but the radio said it could have tipped any way. What if it had tipped toward Mom’s building. Eric must be so scared!And I was terrified. I wanted to go home and get into bed with the blankets over my head until the danger was gone. But first, I wanted to tell my brother that Mom was OK. I had to tell him, who else would? Nothing was as it had been, but Eric had to know that Mom was OK.As I walked through the halls looking into empty classrooms, I started thinking about the last time the Towers were bombed, in 1993. I was 8. It was snowing. My Mom didn’t work on Fridays back then, so I wasn’t scared. I didn’t understand what had happened, or why we were sitting in the house watching the TV news when we could have been outside playing in the snow. I knew her office was across the street form the towers, but it didn’t seem like a big deal.Then, a couple weeks later, we ran into a friend of Mom’s on the subway. She was a healthy looking woman breathing oxygen through a tube in her nose. I asked my Mom, in the way only an 8-year old can, why the woman had a tube in her nose. My Mom told me that she’d been in the Trade Center when it was bombed, that she’d been trapped in the dark, walking down an endless staircase, not sure if she’d make it to the bottom. Mom said the stairwell had filled with choking smoke, and some people ran down, pushing anyone else out of their way. The oxygen was helping Mom’s friend recover. Oh. I was still 8, but I sure understood the danger a little better.What if the bombing hadn’t been on a Friday, Mom? What if you’d been at work? What if it was on a Tuesday?Finally, I found Eric. He was with a school administrator, who had collected children whose parents worked in the towers. They were trying to contact Mom by phone, but of course, as I’d already discovered, the phones were dead. They hadn’t thought to try Dad’s cell. My brother, a jokester with a constant mischievous smile on his face, was near tears.“Mom’s OK,” I said, now near tears my self. I think I hugged him, I sure hope I did.